麒麟-书评

　　国家的枪和电影MUNICH 1

　　"陆臻心念电转，卸走了桌上那台电脑的硬盘，拿给夏明朗。"
　　唔。。。这个细节很意味深长。。。总觉得桔子写这个细节大约不是为了表现陆臻的鬼使神差的念头让这次任务有了重大的突破。那会是什么意图呢？忽然想起以前看MUNICH里的一段话。原话不记得了，大致意思是说不要去了解你的敌人，因为了解后，你会发现原来敌人也是有血有肉的，你会去占在对方的立场去理解他们的处境，然后自己就会很纠结。这个硬盘里面有什么呢？？嗯，莫非能成为陆臻和夏明朗交锋的另一个切入？
　　-
　　这个情节的设定让我想起电影以78年奥运会为背景的电影Munich。其实两个故事有不少类比的地方。Munich男主Avner作为Mossad 探员（Mossad相当于以色列特种部队）接受国家召唤接受绝密认为对巴勒斯坦谋杀以色列运动员的那批恐怖人员11人进行暗杀报复。啥是绝密任务？正如夏明朗说的，你不存在了。这里没有陆臻也没有夏明朗。如果出事，国家是不会承认的。在Munich故事里当Avner接受任务时和他的头Ephraim的段对话：Ephraim告诉Avner先从Mossad辞职，他有个新合同。这个新合同就是Mossad没有雇佣Avenr。新合同就是他们之间没有合同雇佣关系。It's a contract that there is no contract.(嗯，中文表达这里听起来好像有点拗口)。当Avenr问他是否有一份合同文件, Ephraim直接了当说没有，相反递给他一张支票，告诉Avenr从现在起officially unofficial. 对比这两种情况是不是很类似？
　　-
　　我很喜欢桔子的这段设定。有的人觉得这个任务太残酷，其实不管承认与否这很真实。至于陆臻和夏明朗究竟谁更正确？我不想下定义，因为没有对错。从国家利益开看，国家需要这样的武器。而一个好的特工或者特种探员，他需要做的只是坚信为了国家，严格的按照上司的指派，不过问目标是谁，只是执行任务，必要是牺牲无辜者。正如在Munich里，Mossad暗杀小组开始怀着美好的目的进行暗杀行动，他们的信念是We kill for our future. We kill for peace.一个好特工，需要有这样的素质。其实我觉得在性格上，陈默天生是吃这碗饭的，甚至比夏明朗合适，技艺高超，冷静沉着，不想多余的问题，目标明确就是完成任务。小花将来也能成为其中的翘楚。至于陆臻，他没有这个天分。陆臻不像方进，他不盲从，善于思考。他善良正直，书香世家出身的他从小受的人文主义影响已经对他打下烙印，已经成为支持他前进的生活信念。无论有着怎样的理由，我很难想象陆臻所谓的成长是改变自己的人生信条。他可以理解这种杀戮，他可以理解夏明朗和他的不得已的决定，但是妥协到把杀戮无辜者是为了光明变成自己的信条。。。这个恐怕很难。正如在Munich里，随着杀戮的进行，爆破专家Robert对这个任务产生了怀疑"We are supposed to be righteous. That's a beautiful thing. And we're losing it. If I lose that, that's everything. That's my soul." 这段话和陆臻的“不会，我的希望在我心里，我不会因为被关在地下，就相信这个世界上没有阳光，这也就是为什么我坚持这样做的原因，只有内心充满了阳光的人，才不会绝望，那么即使环境很差走投无路，我们的心灵还有依靠。”是多么异曲同工。陆臻究竟会怎么做？我很期待。。。
　　-
　　呜，基本潜水看桔子文，看了这章很有感触，临睡前写得匆忙，本想明天写得仔细些，想想就这样吧。再次感谢桔子的精彩文字！

　　国家的枪和电影MUNICH　2

　　I was kind of rush to write 国家的枪和电影MUNICH　last night, and forgot to mentioned one important detail. At the ending of the movie, Avner went back to his New York home after he finsihed the task. His Mossad handler Ephraim flied to New York and asked Avner to rejoin Mossad. Avner refused this offer. He stayed in his Brucklin's home with his wife trying to sought peace.
　　-
　　How will 陆臻 choose for his future? I don't know how Juzi is going to develop the plot. I can understand 陆臻's decision of either staying with or leaving 麒麟 in the end. I don't think I can judge his whatever decision. What is right? What is wrong? Honestly, there is no clear line between them and no justice when issues go to height of the country's benefit. That's why the American pilot said he had no regret of throwing the atom bomb in Japan. As an American, what he did represented American's benefit even though the atom bomb killed tons of innocent people. Actually some scientists couldn't feel that light and felt guilty of the rest of the life for making such nuclear weapon.
　　-
　　Some readers blame 陆臻 lost his standard as a soldier. The first rule of a qualified soldier is to obey the order. I don't agree with this accusation. Let's refresh our memory why 陆臻 broke up with his first lover professor Lam."我不想呆在军区，你知道吧，人事纷繁，我参军，想要的不是这个。""主要是工作上的事，他想让我回城在军区里工作，可是我想留一线"I don't think 陆臻 realized what 麒麟 really meant when he joined it. I doubt if 陆臻 would have joined it if he knew what the truth of 麒麟 was at the very beginning. Obviously 夏明朗 didn't plan to open its window of the dark side to 陆臻 at the beginning either. Like what I mentioned before. Lu is a thinker, a philosopher. He is not a simple soldier. 夏明朗 realized that. Lu Zhen has strong belief to have to be righteous. That's his soul. Without that, is陆臻 still陆臻? I believe we should respect it if陆臻can’t overcome his morality problem and decided to quit 麒麟. Avner left Mossad in the end of the movie. What will Lu Zhen do? I don’t know. I am looking forward to Juzi’s next chapter.
　　-
　　Sorry for typing English. I can’t input Chinese at work. Look forward to Juzi’s update.

该作者现在暂无推文